It is hard to believe a document as
sparse as the 1910 census can tell us almost everything we know
about an individual. That is the case with Ellen Nunan, oldest
daughter of Joseph and Mary Nunan.
From the 1910 census we know Ellen
Nunan Murray was the head of the household at 204 Noe in San
Francisco. The census says she arrived in the United States in
1870 at the age of 19. Her age is stated as 59 in April 1910
and her year of immigration as 1870. If we accept this
information, her brother John Joseph was then 14 years old, and
accompanied her from County Cork, Ireland. However, these ages
do not agree with the information obtained from the Kinsale Parish
records (see Joseph Nunan chapter). According to church
records she would have been 24 years old in 1870 and her brother
John 18. These ages seem much more likely.
Ellen was married five years after
arriving in the United States to Thomas Murray and had five
children, three surviving; Joseph born in 1876, John J.
born in 1880 and Loretta born in 1885. In the census
she is described as a widow having been married 35 years, but we do
not know when her husband died or what his occupation was.
At the time of the 1910 census, all
three of her children lived with her. Loretta is shown as
Loretta Ayers, although her husband is not listed. We know
Loretta was still married and not a widow; she is shown having two
children but they were not living at the same address. Son
Joseph is listed as single, his occupation is "moulder" working in a
foundry, while son John J. appears to be divorced having been
married for 9 years and works as a wagon driver.
Also living with Ellen Murray is
her nephew, John Francis Nunan, and his wife
Anita and baby son,
Raymond. Her brother John Joseph also lives with her. It
is clear that they all live together in her home since she is listed
as the head of the household and the next such designation is at the
next address. The census also tells us this was a rented home.
Helen Nunan remembered "Aunty"
Murray but did not remember that she was her grandfather's sister
Ellen. The last time Ellen Murray is listed in the City
Directory was 1920 living at 132 Fillmore with her brother, John J.
From 1924 to 1932 John J. continued to be listed at the Fillmore
street address as does Joseph and John Murray.
The close relationship of Ellen and
John J. Nunan and their emigration from Ireland followed a pattern
common to the age and culture. After the 1849 famine Irish
families changed their traditions of dividing property into small
portions among all their children. Property was not
automatically passed on to the oldest son. In heritance was
determined by patents based on factors which included their choice
of wife for a son and the dowry she would bring. Daughters
with little or no chance of making a favorable marriage (which
included the responsibility of the care of her husband's parents!)
would often choose to emigrate. They often took jobs to earn
the money for their passage.
There was a tradition of close
relationships between brothers and sisters. An older sister
would often work long and hard in America to send money home for
passage for their siblings. Part of their wages always went
home to help support the families left behind.
In the Nunan family, Ellen as the
older sister, undoubtedly paid the passage for John Joseph.
Their closeness lasted until the end of her life, 28 April 1925.
She is buried in Holy Cross Cemetery, Colma, CA.
Unfortunately, contact between the Nunan descendants and the Murrays
seem to have been lost.